


Do different robotic system contribute to different surgical outcomes? Which Robotic system is better?
With more hospitals introducing robotic assisted arthroplasty, the type of robotic systems used becomes the highlight of the surgery. But do they actually influence the outcome of the surgery?
To understand this, it is important to note the type of robotic knee system used generally and how each differs. Robotic assisted system can either be image based or imageless. Image based system such as CUVIS and MAKO relies on data from CT scans or X Ray in order to do the planning. CT scan of the lower limb is of course related to additional radiation exposure but gives an accurate representation of the patients knee to compute the parameters. Imageless system such as CORI has a clever trick. It uses preexisting parameters of thousands of knee in its database to match the key areas of your knee to generate the data required for planning purposes. In general, this means no additional radiation exposure and it is helpful in planning in revision surgeries.
The system is also divided into fully automatic or semi-automatic. A fully automatic system such as CUVIS means it does the bone cut completely by itself without requiring surgeon to guide them. Semi-automatic system such as MAKO and CORI requires surgeon to participate in the bone cuts. The method of bone cutting also differs here. CORI and CUVIS uses a burr based cutting mechanism whereas MAKO uses saw based for bone cuts. While CORI and MAKO requires surgeon to decide the trajectory of the bone cuts, both have safety mechanism that ensures bone cuts are precise and does not proceed more than the planned cuts.
So is one robotic system superior than the other?
The robotic system , whichever used only provides assistance to the planning done by the surgeon. Each system do have its own advantage and limitation but ultimately, the outcome of the surgery depends on the surgical planning by the surgeon the robotic system only provides basic and general alignment planning. The basic general alignment planning in most cases will provide outcome quite similar to a conventional TKR.
At our center , we provide both image and imageless robotic system depending on patients preference as both systems are priced differently with different implants used. Regardless of the system used, we ensure that the planning is personalized to the patient. Each patients planning is different, each cuts are different and the final alignment is one that matches closely to the patients original knee while respecting the soft tissue around it. This advance planning is what allows our patients to walk faster, independently , with better confidence and return back to their usual activity much faster than others.
To know more about the robotic system used, and how they can benefit you, contact us today to book your appointment.